The number of patients with type 2 diabetes who are treated with insulin is likely to increase rapidly. A variety of insulin compounds and regimens are available, which allows for individualized therapy but complicates the process of establishing the
Computed tomography (CT) and positron-emission tomography (PET) commonly are used in the initial staging of lung cancer and other malignancies. While CT can provide excellent detail on the size and location of tumor masses and adjacent lymph nodes, it
Radiographic studies generally are ordered when children present with extremity injuries, including knee injuries. The Ottawa knee rule is highly sensitive in detecting clinically significant knee fractures. Application of this rule has reduced the ra
Many physicians use a white blood cell count to screen for infection in infants with fever. Studies have found that white blood cell count analysis is not accurate in screening infants for bacterial meningitis and urinary tract infection; its efficacy
The World Health Organization in 1998 suggested using the term "metabolic syndrome" to describe the combination of atherosclerotic risk factors that includes insulin resistance, microalbuminuria, hypercoagulability, dyslipidemia, obesity, and hyperten
Treatment strategies for patients with asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) include the use of inhaled corticosteroids. These inhaled agents have been shown to reduce inflammation, improve symptoms, and reduce exacerbations in patie
Metabolic syndrome is defined as obesity, insulin resistance, dyslipidemia, and hypertension. Persons who have the syndrome are at increased risk for adverse coronary events and stroke. Aggressive management can decrease mortality. Wong and associates
The importance of timely defibrillation in persons in cardiac arrest has been established clearly. Although an eight-minute interval between call dispatch and the arrival of a defibrillation team is considered standard, this criterion has little objec
Early studies with selective beta blockers, such as bisoprolol and metoprolol XL, and with nonselective beta blockers, such as carvedilol, have demonstrated survival benefit in patients with congestive heart failure. A more recent trial of bucindolol
Proximal plantar fasciitis, a common cause of heel pain, theoretically may be caused by partial tearing of the plantar fascia and inflammation at its insertion on the medial tubercle of the calcaneus. Nonsurgical treatments include shoe modifications,
Author: Anne D. Walling
Date: March 1, 2003
Women with abnormal Papanicolaou smear results and other cervical abnormalities usually are investigated further by colposcopy and punch biopsy of suspicious areas. Biopsies can be painful and cause significant bleeding, and even multiple biopsies can provide inadequate sampling of the endocervix and miss significant lesions. Monk and colleagues tested a new device to sample the endocervix. The spiral-shaped brush with stiff bristles was designed to collect samples rich in basal and parabasal cells that can be evaluated cytologically. The authors compared the specimens obtained using the brush with those obtained by punch biopsy in 52 women scheduled for large loop excision of the transformation zone because of abnormal results on a previous cervical biopsy.
All of the patients underwent sampling with the brush followed by punch biopsy, and both were performed by the same investigator using standardized techniques. Punch biopsy was taken of the same cervical areas only after all bleeding had resolved. Each patient scored discomfort using a scale from 0 to 4 and the investigators estimated bleeding on a scale from 0 to 3 following each procedure. A local anesthetic was then administered, and large loop excision of the transformation zone was performed. Cytologic findings on the three samples were compared.
Complete data were available for 47 of the 52 patients. Biopsy specimens taken with the brush were inadequate for assessment in eight women; in five of these, the punch biopsy specimens also were unsuitable for diagnosis. Only one of the remaining three women had a lesion identified by punch biopsy that was not detected on the brush specimen. Samples taken by large loop excision showed significant pathology in 39 women, of whom 31 had high-grade lesions and one had invasive cervical cancer. The punch biopsy correlated with high-grade disease in 53.1 percent of cases, whereas the brush biopsy specimens correlated in 79.3 percent when cell block techniques were used in preparation and in 76.7 percent when liquid cytology techniques were used (see the accompanying table on page 1081).
Patients scored the punch biopsy as significantly more painful than the brush technique. Pain scores of two or more were given by 17 women for punch biopsy but only by three for the brush sampling. Bleeding was also significantly less with the brush technique. Following punch biopsy, 28 of 47 women bled for more than one minute and required repeated operator intervention to control bleeding. Only two patients bled for more than one minute following brush sampling.
The authors conclude that the brush technique provides adequate sampling for the identification of cervical pathology with reduced patient discomfort and bleeding. With the brush technique, a larger proportion of the cervical surface area can be sampled, and the results are comparable to those of punch biopsy. They recommend that the brush technique be more widely used to evaluate women with suspicious cervical pathology, except when samples of the subepithelial stroma are needed to assess invasion.
EDITOR'S NOTE: A device that offers comparable results to punch biopsy with less pain and bleeding and is easier to perform is very welcome. Innovations usually result in procedures becoming restricted to use by the subspecialist; this one could mean that many more women would be investigated by their family physicians instead of being immediately referred for punch biopsy. Nevertheless, much depends on the skill of the operator, and we must not embrace a promising technology without making sure that the risk of missing the patient with invasive carcinoma has been clarified. We need large studies of the use of this technique in primary care. If a simpler and more acceptable technique becomes available, it could play an important role in reducing the continuing death rate of about 4,000 women in the United States every year from cervical cancer. Many of these cases result from women not following up after suspicious Pap smears because the next stage of investigation was unacceptable or inaccessible for financial or other reasons.--A.D.W.
Anne D. WallingMonk BJ, et al. A stiff bristled, spiral-shaped ectocervical brush:a device for transepithelial tissue biopsy.Obstet Gynecol December 2002;100:1276-84.COPYRIGHT 2003 American Academy of Family PhysiciansCOPYRIGHT 2003 Gale Group